Facebook Twitter
  • Home
  • Perspectives
  • Articles
  • Columns
  • Platform
  • Poetry
  • Literature
  • Write for us
Search
Facebook Twitter
65.5 F
Los Angeles
Thursday, June 19, 2025
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Media Monitors Network (MMN)
Advertise with MMN
  • Home
  • Perspectives
    • Jerusalem Israel Palestine Dome of The Rock Golden Dome

      The Abraham Accords undermined much-needed peace with Palestinians

      World Map

      Global disturbing disparities

      Globe Algeria Niger Mali Africa

      There is always a price to pay for befriending the Zionists

      Illegal Israeli Settlements

      Antisemitism claims mask a reign of political and cultural terror across…

      The Flower - Pakistan Monument at Night

      Israel in the vanguard of India’s mounting conflict with Pakistan

  • Articles
    • Man studying religious book

      Ishmael and Isaac: An Essay on the Divergent Moral Economies of…

      Mahmoud Abbas

      May Your Home Be Destroyed

      Netanyahu Lighting Hanukah Candles with His Wife and Sons

      Bibi’s Son or: Three Men in a Car

      The Map of Greater Israel

      The Man Who Jumped

      West Bank - Palestine

      Cry, Beloved Country

  • Columns
    • Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Steps Left for Electing Progressives and Defeating Republicans in the Midterms

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      Nancy Pelosi Could Get Us All Killed

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      ‘Fortress Mentality’ Among U.S. Leaders Has Trapped Us in a Cycle…

      Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Grassroots Organizing Should Dump Biden and Clear the Path for a…

      Corporate Media Are Focusing on Race -- and Dodging Class

      Biden Refuses to Mention the Worsening Dangers of Nuclear War. Media…

  • Platform
    • Hanukkah Lights

      Hanukkah is not hypocrisy

      The Washington Post

      “Preemptive war could risk millions of casualties. But….”

      When they shout: "We strongly condemn…"

      68

      Why Iran won’t attack Israel

      Is One Iraqi’s Self-Hatred Newsworthy?

  • Poetry
  • Literature
  • Write for us
Home Perspectives Gupkar Declaration: An Absolute Fallacy
  • Perspectives

Gupkar Declaration: An Absolute Fallacy

By
Ghulam Nabi Fai
-
August 31, 2020
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Linkedin
ReddIt
Email
Print
Tumblr
Telegram
Mix
VK
Digg
LINE
Viber
Naver
    Kashmir Security Patrol

    On August 22, 2020, the pro-India leadership in Srinagar (Capitol city of Kashmir) issued Gupkar Declaration, stating that they “are committed to strive for the restoration of Articles 370 and 35A, the Constitution of J&K and the restoration of the State.” Let us analyze the Declaration dispassionately but from a Kashmiri perspective.

    The Gupkar Declaration says, “The series of measures undertaken on 5th August 2019 were grossly unconstitutional.” But Gupkar Declaration fails to mention that these measures also contravene the UN Security Council resolutions #122 and #126 adopted on January 24, 1957, and December 2, 1957, respectively. These resolutions prohibit any unilateral action targeted at changing the disputed nature of the State of Jammu and Kashmir.

    It is important to mention here that the United Nations Security Council Resolution # 122 “reaffirms the affirmation of its resolution 91 (1951) and declares that the convening of a constituent assembly as recommended by the General council of the ‘All Jammu and Kashmir National Conference’ and any action that assembly may have taken or might attempt to take to determine the future shape and affiliation of the entire State or any part thereof, or any action by the parties concerned in support of any such action by the assembly, would not constitute a disposition of the State in accordance with the above principle.”

    Leaving aside linguistic and strategic maneuvering, the Gupkar Declaration leads us to one conclusion: that autonomy is the only option. But the present situation in Kashmir has also made it abundantly clear that the autonomy is unjust, untenable and not acceptable to the people of Kashmir. The Aazadi is the only catchphrase of resistance on the streets of Kashmir which does not mean autonomy but the right to self-determination.

    When Arundhati Roy, an internationally known Indian human rights activist was asked on October 3, 2019, what do the people of Kashmir want, she responded: “I don’t think that they could have been clearer. They’ve been saying it for 70 years. They’ve been saying it loudly. They’ve been saying it with their blood since 1990. Of course, it’s self-determination. You know, of course, it’s self determination.”

    Now the question arises why should some friendly country endorse the Gupkar Declaration which goes against the UN Security Council resolutions and more importantly against the wishes and will of the people of Kashmir.

    Here are a few possibilities:

    • i. It could be due to ignorance or disregard of the inalienable right to self-determination that Gupkar Declaration is being invoked.
    • ii. There exists apprehension that, whether on account of its present internal weaknesses or under external pressure, the Government of Pakistan will be forced to dilute its stand on Kashmir.
    • iii. Being here in the west, we smell that the two ideas are being discussed between the few world capitols and Islamabad on one side and these capitols and India on the other. First, turning the Line of Control (LoC) into a permanent international border. Such an option is an insult to the intelligence of the people of Kashmir. It also cynically mocks their suffering. The people of Kashmir revolted against the status quo; how can they accept the status quo as a settlement? And second, autonomy or self-governance for Kashmir within the Indian Union. The policymakers of these capitols view the Kashmir dispute as a problem between Srinagar and New Delhi, which can be solved by improving their relations. Pakistan, they feel, can be mollified easily. They have consistently sought to dodge the question of sovereignty over Kashmir when that is the heart of the issue and it can neither be finessed nor be evaded. There seems to be an inherent incapacity to empathize with suffering populations unless some political advantage can be derived from a pretended concern.
    • iv. There is also a serious discussion going on in many important Capitols to pursue the Musharraf formula to resolve the Kashmir dispute. If one did not know the authorship of the Musharraf formula and were asked to guess it, one would say that a fairly clever strategist has crafted it to confuse the whole issue and, in the bargain, to throw dust in the eyes of world powers.

    The world powers forget that ‘Restoration of Article 370,’ or ‘self-governance,’ or ‘Musharraf’s formula’, or ‘Autonomy’ is a clear fallacy. Here you will have to rely on a provision of the Indian Constitution. All Constitutions of the world are subject to amendments and the Indian Constitution is no exception. If not now, in the foreseeable future, as India did on August 5, 2019, this provision can be deleted from the Constitution and the move will not even need a debate in the Indian Parliament.

    The world powers also need to know that Kashmiris have had the experience of limited autonomy, which was first practiced under a personal understanding between Nehru, then the prime minister of India and Sheikh Abdullah, then the prime minister of Jammu & Kashmir and later provided for by Section 370 of the Indian Constitution. It was eroded and eventually whittled away by the forces of circumstances.

    In conclusion, the United Nations resolutions on Kashmir acquire continuing decisive importance from two crucial factors. One, they constitute the only international agreement freely negotiated between India and Pakistan on the future status of Kashmir. Two, they embody the only principle on whose basis a just and durable settlement of the problem can be achieved- — the principle of freedom of choice by the people concerned. Therefore, it is fair to say that no settlement of the status of Kashmir will hold unless it is explicitly based on the principles of self-determination and erases the so-called line of control, which is in reality the line of conflict.

    • TAGS
    • abdullah
    • above
    • absolute
    • accept
    • acceptable
    • account
    • achieved
    • action
    • activist
    • adopted
    • advantage
    • affirmation
    • against
    • agreement
    • article
    • aside
    • asked
    • assembly
    • attempt
    • August
    • autonomy
    • Bargain
    • based
    • basis
    • being
    • between
    • blood
    • border
    • called
    • capitol
    • changing
    • choice
    • circumstances
    • City
    • clear
    • clearer
    • committed
    • concern
    • concerned
    • conclusion
    • conference
    • conflict
    • confuse
    • consistently
    • constitution
    • continuing
    • control
    • could
    • council
    • country
    • course
    • crucial
    • debate
    • decisive
    • declaration
    • declares
    • delhi
    • determination
    • determine
    • discussed
    • discussion
    • dispute
    • disregard
    • due
    • dust
    • easily
    • entire
    • eventually
    • exists
    • experience
    • external
    • factors
    • fails
    • fallacy
    • first
    • for
    • forced
    • forces
    • foreseeable
    • forget
    • formula
    • freedom
    • friendly
    • future
    • general
    • going
    • governance
    • government
    • guess
    • heart
    • hold
    • human
    • Human Rights
    • ideas
    • ignorance
    • importance
    • important
    • Improving
    • India
    • indian
    • inherent
    • intelligence
    • internal
    • international
    • internationally
    • issue
    • issued
    • Jammu
    • Jammu and Kashmir
    • january
    • Kashmir
    • kashmiri
    • Kashmiris
    • later
    • leadership
    • leads
    • leaving
    • limited
    • measures
    • mention
    • might
    • minister
    • mocks
    • move
    • musharraf
    • national
    • nations
    • nature
    • negotiated
    • neither
    • option
    • other
    • Pakistan
    • parliament
    • Part
    • parties
    • people
    • permanent
    • personal
    • perspective
    • policymakers
    • political
    • possibilities
    • powers
    • present
    • pressure
    • prime
    • principle
    • principles
    • Pro
    • problem
    • pursue
    • question
    • reaffirms
    • reality
    • relations
    • resistance
    • resolution
    • resolutions
    • resolve
    • responded
    • restoration
    • revolted
    • right
    • rights
    • saying
    • second
    • security
    • Security Council
    • seems
    • series
    • serious
    • settlement
    • shape
    • sheikh
    • should
    • side
    • since
    • situation
    • smell
    • sought
    • sovereignty
    • srinagar
    • stand
    • state
    • State of Jammu and Kashmir
    • status
    • strategic
    • streets
    • strive
    • subject
    • suffering
    • support
    • t
    • taken
    • targeted
    • the United Nations
    • their
    • there
    • these
    • think
    • throw
    • turning
    • UN
    • under
    • understanding
    • unilateral
    • union
    • united
    • United Nations
    • United Nations Security Council
    • unjust
    • unless
    • untenable
    • US
    • view
    • weaknesses
    • west
    • whether
    • which
    • whole
    • whose
    • wishes
    • within
    • world
    • would
    • years
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
    Linkedin
    ReddIt
    Email
    Print
    Tumblr
    Telegram
    Mix
    VK
    Digg
    LINE
    Viber
    Naver
      Previous article412 patients recover from COVID-19 in Uzbekistan
      Next articleThe Choice Voters Will Make
      Ghulam Nabi Fai
      Ghulam Nabi Fai

      Dr. Ghulam Nabi Fai is the executive director of the Washington, DC-based Kashmiri American Council. He contributed this article to Media Monitors Network (MMN).

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Steps Left for Electing Progressives and Defeating Republicans in the Midterms

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      Nancy Pelosi Could Get Us All Killed

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      ‘Fortress Mentality’ Among U.S. Leaders Has Trapped Us in a Cycle of Militarism

      Google Search

      MMN @ Google Play Store MMN @ Amazon Appstore

      MMN @ TwitterMMN @ FacebookMMN Feed

      EDITOR PICKS

      Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Steps Left for Electing Progressives and Defeating Republicans in the Midterms

      August 31, 2022
      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      Nancy Pelosi Could Get Us All Killed

      August 1, 2022
      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      ‘Fortress Mentality’ Among U.S. Leaders Has Trapped Us in a Cycle...

      July 25, 2022

      POPULAR POSTS

      Top 6 thủ môn Real nổi tiếng được nhiều người yêu thích

      Top 6 thủ môn Real nổi tiếng được nhiều người yêu...

      May 27, 2023
      167

      The Origin of Freemasonry: The Crusaders & Templars

      April 23, 2003

      Sharon to Peres: We Control America

      November 20, 2001

      POPULAR CATEGORY

      • Perspectives13563
      • News7530
      • World6105
      • Asia4338
      • Africa1648
      • Columns1370
      • Health1070
      • Australasia1017
      • Articles786
      ABOUT US
      Media Monitors Network (MMN) is a non-profit, non-partial and non-political platform for those serious Media Contributors and Observers who crave to know and like to help to prevail the whole truth about current affairs, any disputed issue or any controversial issue by their voluntary contributions with logic, reason and rationality.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      Facebook Twitter
      • About MMN
      • Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Contact
      Copyright © 2000 - MMN International Inc. All rights reserved.
      Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
      All other brands, logos, and product names are registered
      trademarks or service marks of their respective owners.
      ResponsiveVoice-NonCommercial licensed under 95x15
      MORE STORIES
      Power of football inspires team effort towards development goals

      Power of football inspires team effort towards development goals

      June 18, 2025
      Afghan women face near total social, economic and political exclusion

      Afghan women face near total social, economic and political exclusion

      June 17, 2025