Facebook Twitter
  • Home
  • Perspectives
  • Articles
  • Columns
  • Platform
  • Poetry
  • Literature
  • Write for us
Search
Facebook Twitter
64.3 F
Los Angeles
Friday, June 20, 2025
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Media Monitors Network (MMN)
Advertise with MMN
  • Home
  • Perspectives
    • Jerusalem Israel Palestine Dome of The Rock Golden Dome

      The Abraham Accords undermined much-needed peace with Palestinians

      World Map

      Global disturbing disparities

      Globe Algeria Niger Mali Africa

      There is always a price to pay for befriending the Zionists

      Illegal Israeli Settlements

      Antisemitism claims mask a reign of political and cultural terror across…

      The Flower - Pakistan Monument at Night

      Israel in the vanguard of India’s mounting conflict with Pakistan

  • Articles
    • Man studying religious book

      Ishmael and Isaac: An Essay on the Divergent Moral Economies of…

      Mahmoud Abbas

      May Your Home Be Destroyed

      Netanyahu Lighting Hanukah Candles with His Wife and Sons

      Bibi’s Son or: Three Men in a Car

      The Map of Greater Israel

      The Man Who Jumped

      West Bank - Palestine

      Cry, Beloved Country

  • Columns
    • Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Steps Left for Electing Progressives and Defeating Republicans in the Midterms

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      Nancy Pelosi Could Get Us All Killed

      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      ‘Fortress Mentality’ Among U.S. Leaders Has Trapped Us in a Cycle…

      Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Grassroots Organizing Should Dump Biden and Clear the Path for a…

      Corporate Media Are Focusing on Race -- and Dodging Class

      Biden Refuses to Mention the Worsening Dangers of Nuclear War. Media…

  • Platform
    • Hanukkah Lights

      Hanukkah is not hypocrisy

      The Washington Post

      “Preemptive war could risk millions of casualties. But….”

      When they shout: "We strongly condemn…"

      68

      Why Iran won’t attack Israel

      Is One Iraqi’s Self-Hatred Newsworthy?

  • Poetry
  • Literature
  • Write for us
Home Articles A reply to Uri Avnery’s recent "Death of a Myth"
  • Articles

A reply to Uri Avnery’s recent "Death of a Myth"

By
Jonathan Cook
-
May 17, 2005
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Linkedin
ReddIt
Email
Print
Tumblr
Telegram
Mix
VK
Digg
LINE
Viber
Naver

    I couldn’t help but chuckle as I read Uri Avnery’s recent offering, "Death of a Myth" [1], about the deathbed confession of Naomi Shemer regarding "Jerusalem of Gold", her song that became a second Israeli national anthem after the Six-Day War of 1967.

    The Israeli public was apparently duped: Shemer had plagiarised the song from a Basque lullaby she had heard a few years earlier. Her defence was that the melody had been absorbed into her subconscious.

    As, Avnery implicitly admits, no one was more fooled than he. At the time of the Six-Day War, he was a member of the Knesset and unsuccessfully tried to pass a law to have the song replace the national anthem, "Hativkah" or "The Hope".

    Avnery believed that "Jerusalem of Gold" better captured the spirit of a national people than "Hativkah", which had been written half a century before the establishment of Israel. His objection to Hatikvah is that it is the "hymn of a dispersed religious ethnic community rather than the anthem of sovereign state".

    Avnery, leader of the small Israeli peace movement Gush Shalom, adds: "Even worse, more than 20% of the citizens of Israel are not Jews at all, and it is not healthy that so many citizens cannot identify with the anthem and the flag of their state."

    A major problem with the Hatikvah national anthem is that includes Zionist lines of longing such as the following: "As long as deep in our heart/ The soul of a Jew yearns,/ And towards the East/ An eye looks to Zion;/ Our hope is not yet lost."

    "Jerusalem of Gold", or so Avnery still claims, is a more inclusive song than "Hatikvah". "I thought that if I proposed Naomi Shemer’s song as a national anthem, I might be able to build a consensus for the idea of changing the existing one."

    It would be nice to believe Avnery’s account of his behaviour and motives in the late 1960s in relation to promoting this "immortal song" as he calls it. But I suspect this retrospective view of his thinking around the time of the Six-Day War is another dose of the myth-making which Shemer indulged in for most of her life.

    The evidence? Let’s consider the following account of Avnery’s position – not with the benefit of nearly 40 years of personal hindsight but from a book written a few years after 1967. Fouzi el-Asmar, an Arab intellectual from Lod who was much persecuted by the Israeli authorities, was working in Tel Aviv’s leftwing media with Avnery at the time of the Six-Day War.

    In his book "To Be an Arab in Israel" (unfortunately, long out of print), el-Asmar recalls the extremely fearful and tense popular atmosphere in Israel just before the outbreak of war – and the extreme change of mood that swept the country after Israel’s rapid victory over the Arab armies arrayed against it.

    He also speaks of his disenchantment with leftwing Jews he once considered friends. "I was shocked again and again by meeting people whom I had known to have liberal and progressive stands", he wrote. He asked himself the following question: "What pushed them to think of peaceful solutions before the war and why have they neglected the struggle for peace now?"

    His suspicion was that the positions of most of these progressive Israeli Jews had not really been driven by a sense of justice or a belief in equality and coexistence between Jews and Arabs inside Israel, but by their own fears that the country might be defeated in the war and overrun by hostile Arab armies. A public record of having sided with the Arabs, they hoped, might save them.

    El-Asmar singles out Avnery for particularly harsh criticism. His shock at Avnery’s change of heart was all the greater because he admired Avnery for his outspoken criticism of the government in 1956 over the massacre by the Israeli army of 49 unarmed Arab citizens in the village of Kfar Kassem.

    During the 1967 war, Avnery "was writing the editorials of the daily Daf [newspaper] which had now become totally engulfed by extreme chauvinism. In contrast to his stated position before the war, Avneri [sic] did not even call for a halt to the hostilities. Not only did he resign himself to the fact that [the war] had broken out, but in his editorials he called for a continuation of the war."

    In "Death of a Myth", Avnery admits that the popular impression that the Six-Day War was a desperate war of national defence was false.

    "Years later," he writes, "it became clear to historians that there had been no real danger to the state, that the neighboring countries has not intended to attack but merely to bluff, that Israel’s victory had been no miracle but the result of meticulous preparations."

    But Avnery omits to tell us what he was writing at the time of the war. El-Asmar is more helpful. He quotes from an editorial written by Avnery during the fighting which has more than an echo of Israeli army chief Moshe Yaalon’s infamous remark about using extreme force to "burn" into the Palestinian and Arab consciousness the lesson that Israel can never be defeated.

    "The battle cannot end at this moment," writes Avnery. "If it stops now, before a decisive position is reached, we must be aware that the casualties might be in vain, and that we have no way of being sure that the war will not break out again, after a period of calm. Right now the objective is to see that the Israeli army’s historical victory will bring true peace."

    In another editorial headlined "The objective – Damascus", Avnery wrote: "This war cannot end without an action against the Syrians. We must either fight against them or receive an immediate surrender as a clear and open admission of defeat of the policy of ‘popular war of liberation’."

    El-Asmar continues: "Avneri supported the annexation of East Jerusalem and voted with the parties of the National Unity Government in the Knesset on this issue, although he later withdrew from the position."

    El-Asmar then tells us with particular revulsion of Avnery’s support for Shemer’s song "Jerusalem of Gold". "Avneri had been known for his opposition to the Israeli national anthem ‘Hatikvah’ as this anthem could never represent all the citizens of the country. But I never imagined the day would come when Avneri would suggest an even more chauvinistic song, ‘Jerusalem of Gold’, as an alternative."

    Rather than savouring the chance to be embraced by Avnery’s proposed alternative national anthem, el-Asmar writes: "In this song, composed by Naomi Shemer, the following was said of Arab Jerusalem: ‘How did the water cisterns dry up, the market place is empty. No one visist the Holy Mount in the Old City.’

    "In other words," writes el-Asmar, "a metropolis such as Jerusalem could be considered by the writer to be empty of people simply because Jews were not filling the streets."

    It was not only Shemer who thought in these offensive Zionist terms. We know from his unwavering support for "Jerusalem of Gold" over many decades that Avnery thought the same.

    It is fortunate for Avnery that this book, one of the few accounts of the early Israeli left written in English by an Arab citizen, has been almost impossible to obtain since it was printed in 1976.

    No one should hold it against Avnery that he has changed his positions repeatedly during the nearly six decades of Israeli history. But let him not judge the confessions of Naomi Shemer until he is a prepared to make a confession or two himself.

    Note:

    [1]. "Death of a Myth"
    by Uri Avnery
    http://world.mediamonitors.net/content/view/full/14827/

    • TAGS
    • about
    • account
    • accounts
    • action
    • admission
    • admits
    • after
    • again
    • against
    • almost
    • alternative
    • another
    • anthem
    • apparently
    • Arab
    • Arabs
    • armies
    • around
    • asked
    • attack
    • authorities
    • battle
    • became
    • because
    • become
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
    Linkedin
    ReddIt
    Email
    Print
    Tumblr
    Telegram
    Mix
    VK
    Digg
    LINE
    Viber
    Naver
      Previous articleWhy John Bolton should not be confirmed as US Ambassador to the UN, and why Condoleeza Rice should resign
      Next articleConfirmation of Koran Desecration, Abuse & Torture of Muslim Prisoners
      Jonathan Cook
      Jonathan Cook
      Jonathan Cook won the Martha Gellhorn Special Prize for Journalism. His latest books are Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the Middle East (Pluto Press) and Disappearing Palestine: Israel's Experiments in Human Despair” (Zed Books). His new website is www.jonathan-cook.net. He contributed this article to Media Monitors Network (MMN).
      Facebook

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Man studying religious book

      Ishmael and Isaac: An Essay on the Divergent Moral Economies of the Quran and the Torah

      Mahmoud Abbas

      May Your Home Be Destroyed

      Netanyahu Lighting Hanukah Candles with His Wife and Sons

      Bibi’s Son or: Three Men in a Car

      Google Search

      MMN @ Google Play Store MMN @ Amazon Appstore

      MMN @ TwitterMMN @ FacebookMMN Feed

      EDITOR PICKS

      Progressives Must Fight With -- and In -- the Democratic Party

      Steps Left for Electing Progressives and Defeating Republicans in the Midterms

      August 31, 2022
      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      Nancy Pelosi Could Get Us All Killed

      August 1, 2022
      Tax Revelations and Corporate Media Won’t Defeat Trump

      ‘Fortress Mentality’ Among U.S. Leaders Has Trapped Us in a Cycle...

      July 25, 2022

      POPULAR POSTS

      Top 6 thủ môn Real nổi tiếng được nhiều người yêu thích

      Top 6 thủ môn Real nổi tiếng được nhiều người yêu...

      May 27, 2023
      167

      The Origin of Freemasonry: The Crusaders & Templars

      April 23, 2003

      Sharon to Peres: We Control America

      November 20, 2001

      POPULAR CATEGORY

      • Perspectives13563
      • News7531
      • World6105
      • Asia4338
      • Africa1648
      • Columns1370
      • Health1071
      • Australasia1017
      • Articles786
      ABOUT US
      Media Monitors Network (MMN) is a non-profit, non-partial and non-political platform for those serious Media Contributors and Observers who crave to know and like to help to prevail the whole truth about current affairs, any disputed issue or any controversial issue by their voluntary contributions with logic, reason and rationality.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      Facebook Twitter
      • About MMN
      • Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Contact
      Copyright © 2000 - MMN International Inc. All rights reserved.
      Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
      All other brands, logos, and product names are registered
      trademarks or service marks of their respective owners.
      ResponsiveVoice-NonCommercial licensed under 95x15
      MORE STORIES
      WHO issues first global guideline to improve pregnancy care for women with sickle cell disease

      WHO issues first global guideline to improve pregnancy care for women...

      June 18, 2025
      Power of football inspires team effort towards development goals

      Power of football inspires team effort towards development goals

      June 18, 2025